Comparing traditional AI to software agents and agentic AI - AWS Prescriptive Guidance

Comparing traditional AI to software agents and agentic AI

The following table provides a detailed comparison of traditional AI, software agents, and agentic AI.

Characteristic Traditional AI Software agents Agentic AI

Examples

Spam filters, image classifiers, recommendation engines

Chatbots, task schedulers, monitoring agents

AI assistants, autonomous developer agents, multi-agent LLM orchestrations

Execution model

Batch or synchronous

Event-driven or scheduled

Asynchronous, event-driven, and goal-driven

Autonomy

Limited; often requires human or external orchestration

Medium; operates independently within predefined bounds

High; acts independently with adaptive strategies

Reactivity

Reactive to input data

Reactive to environment and events

Reactive and proactive; anticipates and initiates actions

Proactivity

Rare

Present in some systems

Core attribute; drives goal-directed behavior

Communication

Minimal; usually standalone or API-bound

Inter-agent or agent-human messaging

Rich multi-agent and human-in-the-loop interaction

Decision-making

Model inference only (classification, prediction, and so on)

Symbolic reasoning, or rule-based or scripted decisions

Contextual, goal-based, dynamic reasoning (often LLM-enhanced)

Delegated intent

No; performs tasks defined directly by user

Partial; acts on behalf of users or systems that have limited scope

Yes; acts with delegated goals, often across services, users, or systems

Learning and adaptation

Often model-centric (for example., ML training)

Sometimes adaptive

Embedded learning, memory, or reasoning (for example, feedback, self-correction)

Agency

None; tools for humans

Implicit or basic

Explicit; operates with purpose, goals, and self-direction

Context awareness

Low; stateless or snapshot-based

Moderate; some state tracking

High; uses memory, situational context, and environment models

Infrastructure role

Embedded in apps or analytics pipelines

Middleware or service layer component

Composable agent mesh integrated with cloud, serverless, or edge systems

In summary:

  • Traditional AI is tool-centric and functionally narrow. It focuses on prediction or classification.

  • Traditional software agents introduce autonomy and basic communication, but they are often rule-bound or static.

  • Agentic AI brings together autonomy, asynchrony, and agency. It enables intelligent, goal-driven entities that can reason, act, and adapt within complex systems. This makes agentic AI ideal for the cloud-native, AI-driven future.