View a markdown version of this page

Decision Matrix - AWS Prescriptive Guidance

Decision Matrix

The following matrix provides a structured comparison of the four implementation options across ten capability dimensions. It is intended to help customers, and their WSP/ESPs determine which combination of options best fits their operational requirements.

Capability

Option 1 IAM Role

Option 2 EventBridge

Option 3 Network Monitor

Option 4 Health Events

DX connection config

Yes

No

No

No

CloudWatch DX metrics

Yes

No

No

No

Resource tags / POC info

Yes

No

No

No

Real-time state change alerts

No (polling)

Yes

No

No

Synthetic path monitoring

No

No

Yes

No

AWS-side health events

No

No

No

Yes

Fault isolation (NHI)

No

No

Yes

No

Partition support

All

Verify availability

Verify availability

Verify availability

Additional services required

IAM only

EventBridge

Network Monitor + IAM

EventBridge

Deployment complexity

Low

Medium

Medium

Low

 

Reading this matrix, several patterns emerge. Option 1 is the only option that provides access to connection configuration, CloudWatch metrics, and resource tags — the three data categories most needed for independent troubleshooting. No other option can substitute for it. Option 2 adds real-time alerting but provides no data access. Option 3 adds synthetic path monitoring and fault isolation but depends on Option 1 for metric sharing. Option 4 adds AWS-side health awareness but provides no customer-side data.

The recommended deployment strategy is therefore layered. All organizations should deploy Option 1 as the baseline. Organizations that need real-time alerting should add Options 2 and 4. Organizations that need enhanced diagnostics and fault isolation should add Option 3. In AWS isolated or restricted-access partition environments where EventBridge and CloudWatch Network Synthetic Monitor availability may be limited, Option 1 alone provides substantial operational value.