SEC01-BP02 Identify and validate control objectives
Control objectives translate compliance obligations and identified risks into outcomes your controls must achieve. Validate the controls at a point in time and over a period to produce evidence you can act on and report.
Desired outcome:
-
Your control objectives are defined and traceable to specific compliance requirements and risks.
-
Your controls are implemented and enforced through policy and automation rather than manual effort.
-
You continually evaluate control effectiveness and can identify where a control is failing.
-
You can produce evidence of effectiveness, both point-in-time and over a period, for auditors on demand.
Common anti-patterns:
-
Regulatory requirements, customer expectations, and industry standards are not clearly understood for the business.
-
The chosen cybersecurity frameworks and control objectives do not align with business requirements.
-
Controls are implemented but cannot be measured against the objectives they are meant to satisfy.
-
Teams report control effectiveness manually, so evidence is stale, inconsistent, and slow to produce.
Benefits of establishing this best practice:
-
Controls apply consistently, because they trace to defined objectives rather than individual judgment.
-
Audit preparation shrinks, because evidence of effectiveness is collected automatically.
-
Risk decisions improve, because gaps between objectives and implemented controls become visible.
-
Compliance reporting becomes repeatable across multiple frameworks that share common controls.
Level of risk exposed if this best practice is not established: High
Implementation guidance
A control objective is the outcome a control must achieve, such as "only authorized principals can read customer records." A control is the mechanism that delivers that outcome. Start from objectives derived from your compliance requirements and your threat model, then select controls that satisfy those requirements.
Established cybersecurity frameworks provide a vetted starting set
of objectives. The framework that fits depends on your regulatory
obligations, customer expectations, and industry. Common choices
include
AICPA SOC
Controls fall into two types that work together. Preventative controls stop a non-compliant action before it happens. Service control policies (SCPs) cap the maximum permissions for users and roles in your organization, while resource control policies (RCPs) do the same for resources.
Detective controls identify non-compliant states after they occur, such as rules in AWS Config that report on drift. Review detective findings first, and then automate remediation once you trust a rule's behavior.
Most objectives need both kinds of controls. Detective controls alone leave a window in which misconfigurations are live, and preventative controls alone can block legitimate work.
To validate your controls, deploy managed control sets that align
to your frameworks. Start with
AWS Security Hub CSPM standards, particularly the Foundational
Security Best Practices standard and the CIS AWS Foundations
Benchmark. Complement gaps with
AWS Config conformance packs. If you need external help,
Global Security and Compliance Acceleration Partner bundles
Implementation steps
-
Select frameworks and align objectives: Evaluate common cybersecurity frameworks against your regulatory, business, and industry requirements, then map your control objectives to the frameworks you select.
-
Establish shared responsibility for each objective: Use AWS Artifact to obtain the documentation and reports for your frameworks, and determine which parts of each objective AWS covers and which parts are yours.
-
Enforce with preventative controls: Apply SCPs, resource policies, and role trust policies to prevent non-compliant resource configurations and actions before they take effect.
-
Detect with managed control sets: Deploy Security Hub CSPM standards and AWS Config conformance packs that align to your objectives. Review their findings before you automate any remediation, so you understand each rule's behavior first.
-
Automate control metrics: Use tools such as Security Hub CSPM to provide metrics on your security and control objectives.
Resources
Related best practices:
Related documents:
Related tools: